Editors Liked

  • Improved cameras, screen and battery life
  • Water resistance
  • Taptic engine feedback is neat
  • Powerful dual speakers
  • Starts at 32GB, finally

Editors Didn't Like

  • No headphone jack
  • Iterative design
  • Many of the "groundbreaking" features have been on Android phones for a while
  • Wireless audio ecosystem is immature
  • Jet Black model scratches easily