Editors Liked

  • Outstanding story
  • Inventive gameplay
  • Amazing level of character customization
  • Especially for a first-person shooter
  • Runs smoothly under both Mac OS 10.5 and 10.6
  • Amazing setting under the sea
  • Rich subtext
  • Outstanding character development
  • Graphics
  • Big guns & cool plasmids
  • Sound effects
  • Detailed world

Editors Didn't Like

  • Some minor bugs remain
  • Disappointing frame rate in the final cut scene
  • Final battle seems misplaced
  • Game falters in final moments
  • Repetitive after a couple hours
  • Poor performance under Vista
  • Technical issues mar the experience
  • May be a little too easy for hardcore FPS players