Editors Liked

  • Nuanced take on Bruce Wayne
  • Amazing voice acting from entire cast
  • Excellent visuals
  • Telltale's gameplay formula works well
  • New features keep things fresh
  • Lays the foundations for future episodes and characters
  • The Batmobile's appearance

Editors Didn't Like

  • Combat and QTEs lack impact
  • Hews close to Telltale's formula
  • Batman sequences aren't as strong as Bruce's
  • Overarching narrative could be predictable
  • Confusing relationship with Lt. Gordon and the police